The Screen-time Conundrum

The odds are stacked against us.

I am a bad mother. Here’s the thing: the whole “good enough” motherhood standard that is considered just about acceptable is a myth. We are never good enough, therefore we are bad. As far as I can tell, there’s no discernable difference between good enough and perfect. And perfection is a high bar which I failed to achieve.  I was happy enough with: still alive, has shoes that fit, attends school regularly, gets average grades, occasionally does homework, mostly eats proper food, sleeps at night… far from perfect, but quite an achievement nevertheless.

Jokes aside, there is an aspect of parenting I wish I’d done better even though gods know I did try. I battled to limit my kids’ screen time but I failed.

Epically.

I started well in an era when smart phones and ipads weren’t such a big thing, and by the time firstborn Son was 10, he mostly played Minecraft on his kindle fire (ostensibly purchased so he would read unlimited books, ha ha ha). He loved lego and Minecraft seemed to be online brick by brick creativity. He loved it even more than lego and he created some fabulous worlds. Problem was, he’d never tire of empire building. He got a very basic smartphone at 11 years. But he was a good child and (until he reached adolescence) he’d sweetly (ish) surrender his screens after two or three gentle warnings and one or two threats to his pocket money and/or future screen time. I mostly enforced a no-screens-in-bedrooms-at-night rule. Simples! I thought I’d cracked it.

Adolescence soon wiped the smug grin off my face. Teenage Firstborn Son became much harder to negotiate with, but adolescent Middle Child was my screen time nemesis. Thing is, you cannot outbribe screen time. Negotiations are difficult if you cannot offer something thing more alluring. Being a totalitarian dictator parent involves domestic violence which is frowned upon.

You can threaten to cancel Christmas, but they know you won’t. You could cancel their birthday. You won’t do that either and they know it. They weren’t born yesterday! You can cancel their pocket money, and you do. But realistically, you can only do that once a week. Obviously you can take the device. But confiscating a teenager’s device becomes problematic when they wake up one morning as tall as you but stronger. You kinda hoped you’d have worked your parental magic and raised reasonable beings by the time this happens. You’d be wrong. You realise that expecting your child to act like an adult human (and voluntarily stick to moderate screentime) is wishful thinking because most grown-ups are unreasonably attached to their screen. At the same time, the hormones that make them big and strong also turns back the clock on their painstakingly-taught, hard-learned impulse control. If you do successfully acquired the phone/tablet/laptop/alexa (by cunning,  by stealth or by some world class negotiation) kudos to you.

They will find it.

These are the mini humans who cannot locate their keys/wallet/homework even when it’s in front of their nose and needed immediately – they have you for that donkey work. They will locate the device like sniffer dogs. It’s uncanny!

But: if you have cancelled pocket money for the foreseeable future and you have somehow spirited the devices away, they have nothing left to lose. Now they can refuse veggies/chores/homework/fresh air/ anything they don’t really fancy with impunity. You can neither bribe nor threaten a child when you have nothing to bring to the negotiations. If you can tolerate the screen-withdrawal- behaviour, kudos to you. It’s pretty shoddy. 

Unfortunately, you’re going to have to return the device sooner than you’d like because:

-They need it to talk to their friends. The real ones and the possibly-fake ones. You wish you knew the difference. You hope they do. They really don’t.

– They need it for Google maps (as much as you do). You’d rather they didn’t but you failed to teach them to use an A to Z. You no longer have an A to Z.

– they may need to pay for something and cash may not be accepted (even if you had some to give them)

– They need to access Google Classroom to (pretend to) do their homework- you’ve kinda grown accustomed to knowing where they are

Giving them a dumb phone resolves nothing except they can contact you in an emergency. Obviously, said emergency wouldn’t have arisen if they’d had the smartphone. You could have resolved the emergency remotely if they’d had their sodding smartphone. Now they are lost, can’t text you their location, their oystercard has a balance of 10p, you cannot send them funds to top up their card, and you now have to guess where they may have ended up based on statements like “I can see cars” or “there are shops,” and drive there in rush hour. You cannot complain since this is your fault.

And yes, I know. In the good old bad old days, us Gen X kids would have somehow found our way home because what else were we gonna do? It wasn’t better though, and our collective trauma probably paved the way for GPS technology.

Boomer parents (who bemoan the screen-addled youth of today) thought they had it tough, controlling our screen time in front of the TV. They struggled when there was only one, maximum two (hefty, immovable) screens per house. When a child could not take the family TV, or PC, for that matter, and hide it in their room. They did try though, having been told TV and video games would rot our brains and make us square-eyed. Boomer parents also resented how long we spent on the one and only house phone to our friends, wailing about the cost of telecommunications before 6pm. Rules were established and imperfectly enforced because a) they knew that screens were great childminders and b) we always found ways to defy the rules however strictly they were being enforced. They knew this and we knew that they knew. But they could pretend to believe that we’d only watch CBBC. That us kids would be too smart to fall for the ads on CITV.  Ha ha ha!

This all sounds depressingly familiar to me. Except, instead of one bulky, hard to hide screen, I had to locate and neutralise several devices. Per child. And look, I realise that they’d been given these devices. By me. But sometimes also their (fun) dad. Sometimes even their friends. At least once they’d managed to resuscitate one of my old phones, kept for an emergency. Who knew the emergency was that middle child’s phone had been confiscated!

Just like my boomer parents, I knew the key was good parental discipline. (Ha, ha, ha). But I might not have been the only mother, single or otherwise, who struggled with the fact that there are 2 parents and often only one of these does discipline. The dad gets to be the fun guy. Sometimes, when the fun guy is left in charge of his progeny, screentime rules are relaxed. Sometimes in a spurt of generosity (usually quite overdue) they will purchase an extra screen without installing any parental control apps prior to gifting it to the child. Even though they work in IT. Look, not all dads, ok?

And yes, I knew, you could install apps to help limit the bad while preserving the good. By the time I figured out how to install these (look, I’ve never claimed to be great at technology) it was too late for the boys. I did once manage to lock us all out of a perfectly good tablet when I forgot the 4 digit code I’d set up to keep it child-friendly. It remained functional if you wanted to watch the Teletubbies! The problem is that you need all their devices to be secure at the same time, because if you limit each screen to 2 hours per day, they get 2-6 hours (phone, alexa, ipad/laptop). Plus, you need each of your children’s permission for these apps to be installed. I kid you not. Not gonna lie, I don’t think the tech bros had any incentive to make these apps parent-friendly.  Neither Firstborn Son nor Middle Child were gonna be consenting to parental controls. I managed to bribe a slightly younger Only Daughter to accept these controls. It was pricey, but worth it, I think. Although… I strongly suspect she has found work-arounds, and I have to concede that she’s probably one step ahead of me, just like any normal child!

Who knows, perhaps I’d have somehow aced the screentime conundrum (ha ha ha ha!) But we’ll never know because then COVID happened. And overnight it went from nearly impossible to fooorgedarboudeeet. Now the kids had legitimate reasons to be perma-fused to their screen. In fairness to firstborn Son who was doing his GCSEs that year, and who did actually work hard, it wasn’t a complete disaster. But for middle child, who had no such pressure, it was waaaay too much freedom.

I don’t want to abdicate all maternal responsibility to fun dads, covid, complicated apps and the genius of kids. That’d be wrong. I’d just like it to be acknowledged that it isn’t easy. And the odds are stacked against us. We should like it to be easier. Our kids deserve to be protected. Both boys have seemingly turned out OK (sure, I may be biased). That’s not to say they weren’t exposed to a ton of harmful content because even I am not that much of an optimist. Only Daughter is a work in progress. Sadly I have no doubt that, despite her slightly reduced screentime, she too has witnessed a multitude of things she should have been protected from. That’s on me. I feel bad about that.

This should be a doddle!

Up next:

Before:

2 responses to “The Screen-time Conundrum”

  1. Dear Claire,

    Reading your piece over my morning decaf in the Golden Jubilee Wing actually made me chuckle out loud. As a fellow member of the King’s College Hospital NHS Foundation Trust family – I’m Giles Pemberton, Head of Clinical Informatics and Digital Governance – I feel uniquely qualified to reassure you that you aren’t a bad mother at all. You’re simply suffering from a classic legacy-infrastructure bottleneck.

    Like you, I entered this world in 1974 and became a parent thirty years later. Where our paths diverge is that I’ve always treated domestic life with the exact same rigour I apply to NHS data security. Letting adolescents dictate screen boundaries is rather like letting an unpatched ward terminal connect to the main server without a firewall. Inevitably, chaos ensues.

    Your confusion over parental-control apps needing a child’s permission genuinely baffled me. Why on earth would anyone negotiate software permissions with the end-user? At Denmark Hill, we don’t ask clinical staff if they’d enjoy two-factor authentication before rolling it out. Rather than fiddling with clunky commercial apps, I configured enterprise-grade DNS filtering and MAC-address whitelisting across our home network before my eldest could even spell Minecraft. My wife entirely supports this protocol, largely because she knows that relaxing weekend rules constitutes an unauthorised deviation from our household Acceptable Use Policy.

    Confiscating handsets from strapping teenagers sounds exhausting, which is why I eliminated physical searches entirely. Every approved device in our house must be docked inside a biometric charging safe at 19:30 sharp. Should an unrecognised gadget ever ping our router, my smartwatch vibrates within four seconds and I sever its bandwidth remotely from wherever I happen to be standing. Resurrecting an old phone from a kitchen drawer wouldn’t get my boys past the login screen.

    Even your practical objections are remarkably easy to engineer out of existence. Navigation requires zero reliance on Google Maps once you’ve taught a nine-year-old how to take compass bearings off a laminated Ordnance Survey Explorer map. Financial panics around empty Oyster cards disappear completely when you link them to an automated direct-debit top-up, supplemented by a folded twenty-pound note sewn inside each blazer lining. Homework happens exclusively on a single hardwired desktop terminal in the middle of our dining room, restricted to a whitelist of fourteen educational domains. When my children leave the house, they carry basic brick phones with six pre-programmed numbers and the Snake game permanently disabled. Getting mildly lost in South London without live GPS builds splendid character.

    Lockdown didn’t derail our system either. While other parents panicked in March 2020, I treated the whole affair as a thrilling remote-working deployment sprint. Over a single weekend, I spun up isolated virtual local networks for home schooling and scheduled hard bandwidth cut-offs for 17:00 every afternoon.

    What struck me most about your post was the heavy guilt you carry regarding harmful online content. Fortunately, that’s one burden I’ve spared myself entirely. Because zero unapproved data packets ever cross our threshold, my teenagers’ minds remain completely sanitised. My middle lad, Tobias, is a shining testament to analogue upbringing – he spends two hours every single evening locked inside our garden shed happily polishing his rugby boots and reading physical encyclopaedias in total peace.

    Please stop beating yourself up over a simple systems failure. If you’d like to pop over to IT Governance on your next break, I’d be delighted to talk you through my forty-two-page Family Digital Governance Framework over a herbal tea.

    Warmest regards,

    Giles Pemberton
    Head of Clinical Informatics and Digital Governance
    King’s College Hospital NHS Foundation Trust

    Liked by 1 person

    1. See, I knew it! Not all dads! You, dear Giles, are my hero! Your kids must be the luckiest, most well-rounded, self-sufficient kids ever! I’m sure they look forward to their enforced shed time… I look forward to getting it right as a grandmother since it’s too late for my kids. I’ll be implementing you protocol, for sure.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply